Recipe: Homemade Bread and Butter Pickles
Here is the recipe you always wanted – Homemade Bread and Butter pickles!
Ever since I can remember we always had pickles in the fridge just waiting for a sandwich or salad to come along! One of my favourites was the Bread & Butter Pickles (the other favourite a reall Dill Pickle).
I was told the pickles are called Bread and Butter pickles because they are so good you can eat them with just bread and butter! I have also heard that during the American Depression people were very poor with little to eat but bread, butter and the cucumbers that were plentiful so quickly became a food favourite.
Years ago (early 1990s I had a small seasonal cafe where I made all of the cakes, jams, preserves and pickles myself. My Bread & Butter pickles were so popular that they would sell out almost immediately.
I have always used the thin, long cucumbers to make my pickles however this year my allotment has been providing me with cucumbers faster than we can eat them so I decided to make a batch of my favourite pickles. If you make them I hope you like them as much as I do.
How do your make them?
You need to set aside a couple of hours to make them even though they are really simple to do. First of all thinly slice your cucumbers and onions and layer them in a bowl with the salt.
Leave this for about 3 hours before rinsing and draining.
Meanwhile, put all of the other ingredients in a large pan and bring to the boil. Add the cucumbers and onions and simmer for 2-3 minutes (do not let the liquid boil).
Finally put into sterilised jars and seal. The pickles will last about 6 months however I bet they don’t last that long once you have tasted them!
Here is the recipe:-

- 900 gm cucumbers cut into thin slices
- 350 gm onions sliced very thinly
- 50 gm salt
- 350 mil cider vinegar
- 350 gm caster sugar
- 30 ml mustart seeds (yellow or black)
- 30 ml celery seeds
- 1.25 ml turmeric powder
- 1.25 ml cayenne pepper or chilli pepper - depending how spicy you want them
-
Place the sliced cucumbers and thinly sliced onions into a large bowl
-
Add the salt and mix well together
-
Allow to sit for 3 hours
-
Drain and rinse well under cold running water then drain again
-
Bring all of the other ingredients to the boil in a large pan
-
Add the cucumbers and onions
-
Reduce the heat to simmering and continue cooking for 2 minutes.
-
Do not allow the mixture to boil or the pickles may be too limp (a crunch when you bit into the pickle is part of the pleasure)
-
Pour into hot sterilised jars, top up with the liquid and seal with jam jar covers. Allow to cool before putting on the lids.
-
Enjoy!
I doubled all of the ingredients using 1.8kg of my allotment cucumbers! Friends are already asking for a jar – think I will be making a few more batches!
Please leave a comment below (so I know I am not the only one reading this post!) and tell me what your favourite pickle or chutney is.
If you do make these pickles please leave a comment below and if possible add a photograph on Instagram and tag me (itsmeheidiroberts)
Here are some other seasonal recipes you might like to take a look at.
Blackberry Chutney: Christmas Promise in a Jar
Rhubarb, Strawberry and Ginger Jam
Kolokuthopita – Greek Courgette Pie